Monday, December 12, 2005

The Home-schooling Atmosphere: does it work?

Just the other night I was babysitting for a home schooling family in our area who’s youngest adopted child has ADD, and I was again amazed at how much he had developed over the past few months. Since I had last babysat for them he seemed much calmer; he was able to sit still without constantly moving his hands and head for a little while. He is now able to speak in four word sentences; which is a huge step from what he could say a few months ago. I am not very educated as far as ADD goes (well, unless you count the “slight” cases my brothers have! :) but am convinced that had he not received the one on one training and education he was given at home by his parents, he would be quite beyond our reach as far as communication. I can remember how impressed my mom was when he stood up on stage at our home-school fair to say the ABC’s! It’s wonderful to see what progress he’s making at home…

Even as home schooling gets more popular throughout the U.S., devoted public schooled pupils and parents seem very suspicious and critical of the home schooling system. Can education at home actually work? What about socialization? How will they be exposed to the real world? And my goodness; child training? You must abuse your children! Yes, I’ve heard it all before. My family is active in a small town where just about every person over the age of 40 is or was a teacher for our school. People at our Fitness Center often ask the same questions when curious of or prejudiced against the system. For them, it’s hard to imagine that anything but the traditional method of education can actually work. But in fact, when you hear of successful home schoolers (my older brother *gasp* was a national merit finalist and made it to college with a full ride) it’s often not just the method of education we used, but more the attitude used with it. You can call public school traditional and natural, but from the beginning of time education has started in the home, and the home has been the most natural place to learn. Ask a public schooler if they would rather learn at home with family or at school and with their friends, and they will most likely say at school, because age segregation is such a big thing in America that they can’t even fathom relating to their older or younger siblings for a WHOLE DAY! And that’s one of the big factors that sets public school and home school so far apart; we can relate well with our parents and siblings because we spend every day with them. Elderly people that work out at our fitness center in town are often amazed at how mature I seem; simply because I can hold a conversation with them.

So really, as far as the attitude and atmosphere we kids are exposed to at home, is it that bad that we would be abused, sheltered, isolated, and un-educated? Because as I see it, even young children with ADD or learning disabilities grow faster and more stable when taught by our parents in a loving, natural atmosphere. Nothing is harder on a struggling child than to be tossed around among strange, stiff teachers in an even stranger, ever changing atmosphere where bullying and teasing is never far away. I say let’s quite with the taxes and all; pull your kids out of public school, use your own money for your own books and curriculum, and make sure that your children are provided with the education YOU believe in… most importantly, please make sure that your precious jewels are raised in an atmosphere where they can simply be themselves.

Speaking from my perspective here at home, I would have to say that truly the best and most effective teachers and counselors are our own parents!

Jennifer

P.S. Thanks mom and dad; I love you!

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Jen - Although I went to a public school, I totally agree with you on homeschooling. When I have children, I plan to homeschool them. However, I wanted to present one sad truth to you. At a public school, I saw so many students who did not care about their education and neither did their parents. Sadly, all parents are not as wonderful as yours are - some simply do not care. I'm sure you know this - but I just wanted to present the problem.

The Patriot said...

Yes Lauren; with all the rules, regulations and age segregation in our schools it's no wonder public schoolers have no interest in learning! Which is sad that they would view school as the only education and learning oppurtunity; life IS our education and constant classroom!

Anonymous said...

I could make a long comment, but instead just go to my brother Tait's blog... www.taitzimmerman.com/blog.htm . He has just written a post on education.
He has spent years studying this very critical subject, education and learning are truly his vision and calling in life.

olivebranch said...

I agree a lot with you on the idea of home-schooling, but there are several problems with wide-spread homeschooling,

for one it makes adults not available for other works, and for a second it also increases racial segregation-

if you live in an area dominated by one particular ethnicity and religion, your chance of learning things that relate to other ethnicity & religion becomes much lower.

Another problem with it....

Many of our parents grew up with exactly the problems public-shooling creates, - low level education, "group psychology", different/less technological expertise and a very very biased perspective on history (not their own fault by any means)

This mostly comes down to government funding for schools, poor administration and the desire to deny attrocities of the past and push the "positive" events to the front, to increase "patriotism" and trust in the leaders.

PLUS, the another problem with home-schooling is that it does not breed rebellion.

To some this would seem like a positive thing.

To me I find it disturbing.

For it is when unreasonable teachers have unreasonable views that most youths learn not to trust all authority figures, and not to take things at face value.

All said and done, I think home-schooling should be compulsary also. I think we should make it illegal for children under the age of 8 and without a certain amount of education to enter a big schooling environment....

Before that age, do we even know right from wrong? Do we know who to trust and who not to? Do we know that what we are being told may not be true?

Do we know how much our parents love us, and how much they have sacrificed for us???

For people like me who were in public schools and pre-primary from the age of 4 years old, probably not.

Infact I don't think I have realised quite how much my parents have sacrificed for me even now, and I am very grown up for a 19year old..

Parents do care so much for their children, and do want their children to do well- and as such should be the first ones to provide the children with an education- to prepare their children for the bigger world.

It should not be the job of some under-paid, over-worked, miss-treated and poorly supplied teachers. I feel sorry for them, the responsibility to educate 30 uneducated, often un-disciplined children all in one room.

Great post... Keep it up

maybe you will like my blog if you do not find Teens with similar views... I am a teen- just barely for the next year:)

http://olivebranchoptimism.blogspot.com/

Thomas said...

I was homeschooled almost all of my life and I can greatly attest to its effectiveness. I thrived in the homeschool atmosphere and I heartily believe that I would have been stunted in public (or even private) school. What cracks me up is when people say that homeschoolers grow up to be anti-social! They actually relate very well with people...particularly people more mature than they are! That's a natural consequence of being around your parents all day rather than your peers.